IMF proposes two big new bank taxes to fund bail-outs
Posted on Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Banks and other financial institutions face paying two new taxes to fund future bail-outs, the BBC has learned.
Business editor Robert Peston said the global proposals by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) were "more radical" than most had anticipated.
All institutions would pay a bank levy - initially at a flat-rate - and also face a further tax on profits and pay.
The measures are designed to make banks pay for the costs of future financial and economic rescue packages.
The proposals are likely to horrify banks, especially the proposed tax on pay
Robert PestonBBC Business Editor
Read Robert's thoughts
The IMF documents were made available to governments of the G20 group of nations on Tuesday afternoon and seen by the BBC soon afterwards. The plans will be discussed by finance ministers this weekend.
"The proposals are likely to horrify banks, especially the proposed tax on pay," our business editor said.
"They will also be politically explosive both domestically and internationally."
Insurers, hedge funds and other financial institutions must also pay the taxes, the IMF argues, despite them being less implicated in the recent crisis.
If they were not included, activities currently carried out by banks would be reclassified as, for example, insurance or hedge-fund services to escape the levies.
While the general levy, or "financial stability contribution", would initially be at a flat rate, this would eventually be refined so that riskier businesses paid more.
British chancellor Alistair Darling said the IMF's proposals were "important" and should be welcomed.
"The recognition that banks should make a contribution to the society in which they operate is right," he said.
Global impact
IMF REPORT
International Monetary Fund interim report for the G20 [1.5MB]
Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader
Download the reader here
It was agreed at the G20 summit in London last year that financial institutions and not tax-payers should pay for future bank rescue packages.
Since then several proposals have been put forward by various governments including the so-called "Tobin Tax" on financial transactions. Some nations, including Canada, oppose any new bank taxes.
However no country has yet introduced taxes to pay for future bailouts - arguing that unless the rules were brought in on a coordinated basis, institutions would simply "cherry pick" where they operated, moving to jurisdictions with less tough financial regulation.
The body which represents banks in the UK, the British Bankers' Association said it was concerned about any move which would place the UK industry "at a competitive disadvantage internationally".
"We also need to see all the detail of what is proposed - and how any new levy and tax would apply - to determine the effect it would have", it said.
Party claims
In the light of the UK's looming general election, the IMF proposals were likely to be used for some political point-scoring, our business editor said.
"Labour is bound to claim that the IMF is implicitly criticising the Tories' plan to impose a new tax on banks irrespective of what other countries do - because the IMF paper says that 'international co-operation would be beneficial'.
"I would also start to question my sanity if Gordon Brown doesn't claim credit for putting pressure on the IMF to launch its review of possible bank taxes."
But he added that the Conservatives would say that their bank tax proposals resembled the financial stability contribution.
And the Liberal Democrats would claim that their proposed tax on banks' profits was similar to the second tranche of the IMF proposal.
Business editor Robert Peston said the global proposals by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) were "more radical" than most had anticipated.
All institutions would pay a bank levy - initially at a flat-rate - and also face a further tax on profits and pay.
The measures are designed to make banks pay for the costs of future financial and economic rescue packages.
The proposals are likely to horrify banks, especially the proposed tax on pay
Robert PestonBBC Business Editor
Read Robert's thoughts
The IMF documents were made available to governments of the G20 group of nations on Tuesday afternoon and seen by the BBC soon afterwards. The plans will be discussed by finance ministers this weekend.
"The proposals are likely to horrify banks, especially the proposed tax on pay," our business editor said.
"They will also be politically explosive both domestically and internationally."
Insurers, hedge funds and other financial institutions must also pay the taxes, the IMF argues, despite them being less implicated in the recent crisis.
If they were not included, activities currently carried out by banks would be reclassified as, for example, insurance or hedge-fund services to escape the levies.
While the general levy, or "financial stability contribution", would initially be at a flat rate, this would eventually be refined so that riskier businesses paid more.
British chancellor Alistair Darling said the IMF's proposals were "important" and should be welcomed.
"The recognition that banks should make a contribution to the society in which they operate is right," he said.
Global impact
IMF REPORT
International Monetary Fund interim report for the G20 [1.5MB]
Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader
Download the reader here
It was agreed at the G20 summit in London last year that financial institutions and not tax-payers should pay for future bank rescue packages.
Since then several proposals have been put forward by various governments including the so-called "Tobin Tax" on financial transactions. Some nations, including Canada, oppose any new bank taxes.
However no country has yet introduced taxes to pay for future bailouts - arguing that unless the rules were brought in on a coordinated basis, institutions would simply "cherry pick" where they operated, moving to jurisdictions with less tough financial regulation.
The body which represents banks in the UK, the British Bankers' Association said it was concerned about any move which would place the UK industry "at a competitive disadvantage internationally".
"We also need to see all the detail of what is proposed - and how any new levy and tax would apply - to determine the effect it would have", it said.
Party claims
In the light of the UK's looming general election, the IMF proposals were likely to be used for some political point-scoring, our business editor said.
"Labour is bound to claim that the IMF is implicitly criticising the Tories' plan to impose a new tax on banks irrespective of what other countries do - because the IMF paper says that 'international co-operation would be beneficial'.
"I would also start to question my sanity if Gordon Brown doesn't claim credit for putting pressure on the IMF to launch its review of possible bank taxes."
But he added that the Conservatives would say that their bank tax proposals resembled the financial stability contribution.
And the Liberal Democrats would claim that their proposed tax on banks' profits was similar to the second tranche of the IMF proposal.
Comments
Page Views
Archives
-
▼
2010
(168)
-
▼
April
(141)
- Greece crisis: investors wait on deal details
- Man stabs 28 children in China kindergarten attack
- South Korea holds funeral for sailors killed in si...
- Gordon Brown 'bigot' row overshadows last TV debate
- US releases damning Afghan report ahead of Karzai ...
- Australia plans plain-packaging rule for cigarettes
- SeaWorld killer whale 'caught trainer's hair'
- Chile boy 'kills brother' over PlayStation row
- Panama's Manuel Noriega extradited from US to France
- US Republicans block debate of finance rules reform
- Chocolate lovers 'are more depressive', say experts
- Iraq poll uncertainty threatens civilians, says Am...
- Location chosen for European Extremely Large Teles...
- Mexico leader attacks Arizona's new immigration law
- Goldman Sachs 'profited at clients' expense'
- BP profits double on oil price rises
- Chimps 'feel death like humans
- Oil rig spill off Louisiana could threaten coastline
- UK envoy 'escapes suicide bomb'
- Indian cricket suspends IPL chief Modi for 'corrup...
- Pope leaked memo 'will not affect UK visit'
- South Korea mourns victims of ship sinking
- Landslide victory for Hungary's conservative oppos...
- Indonesia hosts world's biggest Geothermal energy ...
- Political prisoners' wives harassed in Havana
- Jet in first flight from Baghdad to UK in 20 years
- Mississippi tornado leaves 10 dead amid destruction
- Foreign Office apologises for Pope 'condom' memo
- South Korean warship sunk by 'close-range explosion'
- IMF chief Strauss-Kahn tries to ease Greece fears
- Gunmen ambush security official's convoy in Mexico
- Goldman Sachs executives 'boasted of crash profits'
- US Senate climate bill postponed over immigration row
- Lebanese to stage march for secularism
- Global recovery moving faster than expected, says G20
- Arizona signs tough immigration bill despite criti...
- Mumbai's Oberoi hotel reopens after deadly 2008 at...
- Volunteers asked to give seats to stranded passengers
- Guilty plea in New York subway bomb plot
- Police among seven killed in Mexico shoot-out
- 'Holocaust' tax dodger jailed for hiding funds in UBS
- Utah murderer Gardner chooses death by firing squad
- Tackling oil rig disaster 'number one priority' - ...
- 'Terrorists' blamed for attacks amid Thai deadlock
- US man names Pope Benedict in Milwaukee...
- Parties seek boost from leaders' TV ele...
- X-37B military spaceplane launches from Cape Canav...
- North Korea 'to seize property at Kumgang resort'
- Nato ministers consider Afghanistan pull-out plan
- Netanyahu refuses to budge over Jerusalem construc...
- Whaling plan draws anger from green groups
- Recriminations grow over airline costs
- US warns Syria over Scuds-to-Hezbollah claim
- Huang Guangyu, Chinese electronics tycoon, on trial
- Nasa's Solar Dynamics Observatory returns first im...
- Controversial cardinal replaced for Washington Mass
- Leaders prepare for second prime ministerial TV de...
- Detained opposition leader in Sri Lanka parliament
- South Park creators warned over Muhammad depiction
- Early baby survival rate 'static'
- Travel chaos persists despite easing of air lockdown
- China holds national day of mourning for quake dead
- US civil rights leader Dorothy Height dies aged 98
- Brazil awards rights to develop Belo Monte dam
- Saharan states to open joint military headquarters
- Argentina ex-dictator Gen Bignone jailed for 25 years
- IMF proposes two big new bank taxes to fund bail-outs
- iPhone demand boosts Apple profit
- Google reveals government data requests and censor...
- European airports start to reopen for flights
- Cuba's Cardinal Jaime Ortega says country is in cr...
- Web hit by hi-tech crime wave
- US summons Syrian envoy over Hezbollah
- Venezuela celebrates bicentenary with Caracas parade
- Indonesia rejects religions law review
- Public to have say on organ donation incentives
- Space shuttle to return Tuesday
- EU emergency talks called on volcanic ash air chaos
- Thai army moves into Bangkok business district
- UK water use 'worsening global crisis'
- Australia plans tough Great Barrier Reef shipping ...
- World warming to US under Obama, BBC poll suggests
- Space shuttle may face rain delay
- South Korean president in vow over sunken warship
- Behavioural rewards 'work like drugs' for ADHD
- Indian minister Shashi Tharoor quits over cricket row
- Polish President Lech Kaczynski 'in plane crash'
- US suspends Kyrgyzstan-Afghanistan troop flights
- Vatican defends Pope in paedophile letter row
- Thailand police retake opposition TV channel
- Twitter used to predict box office hits
- Four missing West Virginia miners are found dead
- Brazil landslide death toll rises
- Somalia Islamists al-Shabab ban BBC transmissions
- Greece rescue hope sends euro and stocks higherEur...
- Qatari plane bomb-scare diplomat to leave us
- South Africa set for Eugene Terreblanche funeral
- Thailand's red-shirt protesters converge on TV sta...
- Kyrgyzstan's President Bakiyev in talks offer
- Australia halts Sri Lankan and Afghan asylum claims
- Sri Lanka ruling party ahead in polls
- China executes three more Japanese drug smugglers
- Apple reveals new iPhone features
- Obama limits US nuclear arms use
- Flooding in Rio de Janeiro state kills scores
- Kyrgyzstan police 'fire tear gas at Bishkek protes...
- US man sentenced to hard labour in North Korea
- Thai red-shirt protesters march on parliament
- Egypt hosts meeting on recovery of 'stolen treasures'
- Tsunami alert lifted after earthquake hits Indonesia
- 'Suicide bomb' at north-west Pakistan political rally
- Scores rescued from flooded Chinese mine
- Countdown on for predawn launch of shuttle Discovery
- Church abuse scandal spurs new victims groups
- Blast derails train in Russia
- Earthquake rocks western Mexico
- South Korea tanker hijacked by Somali pirates
- Discovery set for morning launch
- South Africa warns against Terreblanche revenge
- Ingushetia hit by suicide attack
- Red-shirts shut down Bangkok's main shopping district
- Battle to stabilise ship aground near Barrier Reef
- U.S. announces new airport security measures
- Afghan's Karzai calls Clinton to discuss fraud com...
- Extremist group demands governors resign, FBI says
- Erykah Badu faces misdemeanor charge for nude walk
- Dynasty actor John Forsythe dies aged 92
- Nine missing as S Korean boat sinks in warship search
-
▼
April
(141)

Leave a Reply